How Harvesting Works with Victor Barber
Download MP3speaker-0 (00:01.784)
Welcome to Forestry Now, where we explore the forces impacting profitable and sustainable management of commercial forests and natural woodlands. I'm Dermot McNally. Today I'm joined by Victor Barber from Western Forestry, who explains how modern timber harvesting works. In this podcast, we focus on everything an owner might need to know about the licensing process and how it feeds into the operational side of harvesting. Victor explains how foresters identify and protect.
Soil, water, biodiversity, and archaeological features while ensuring efficient and effective timber removal can still take place. We also talk about the steps in the application process, why many forest owners choose to hire a forester to manage the entire process, and how long it all takes. But before all that, I asked Victor to introduce himself and tell us about Western Forestry.
speaker-1 (00:58.441)
My name is Victor Barra and I am the harvest manager with Western Forestry Co-op and our main customers really are privately owned forest, mainly farm forest owners in the West and the Northwest and Midlands of Ireland.
speaker-0 (01:13.878)
Brilliant. Okay. So today we're gonna look at how harvesting works with an emphasis on the licensing and operational side. So let's take a scenario like this. A landowner contacts you. She has a forest road in place in her forest, but she's now hoping to apply for a 10-year thinning license and clear file. Maybe you'd give us a broad overview, first of all, of what happens next, and then we can break down each step.
speaker-1 (01:38.764)
Ideally, Darnett person contacts us. We would like to do a quick desktop survey on the site before we go out. So, you know, we can flag stuff that we really need to concentrate on out when we go to do the physical survey on the ground. So off we go then out to the site to do our walkover survey and record all the relevant details on the site. And so you're you're essentially you're just building a plan to start with in your head what sh
sensitivities are around the site, what to look out for, and and to talk through with the owner as well. The the potential ten year work program that's a hand ahead, because that's what you're looking for, is a ten year license. So it's essentially trying to put all the work that you want to do onto that application for the next ten years. So there's there's quite a bit to go through. So there is
speaker-0 (02:28.266)
Okay, perfect. And so maybe we'll ask the same question we asked them, which is that if it's a broadleaf or conifer plantation, is it the same process?
speaker-1 (02:40.79)
Absolutely the same process. And obviously the the work program might be different, but the actual license and the way you apply for it is exactly the same. No difference.
speaker-0 (02:49.902)
Perfect. And here's a question. If the clear fell is gonna be ten years away, do you still have to specify the replanting species or how does that work?
speaker-1 (03:00.534)
Yes, you do. And it's something I suppose we're all getting to grips with and trying to plan that far ahead. for a lot of first generation forest owners, it's maybe ten years away is a long time. And especially with maybe elderly owners, you know, the attitude is not to think that far ahead, but in forest determines we need to to be in that mind frame. So it i it is quite hard to do sometimes because even over the last ten years.
There has come new schemes along the way, like the climate resilience scheme and things like that. So applying today, you c you can't tell what is going to be there if there's going to be any financially incentive schemes or if there's going to be environmental schemes that might suit you better than what does now. But all you can do is your best. And yes, you have. Ideally you're choosing the species that you're going to replant with for ten years' time. Absolutely.
speaker-0 (03:54.22)
Yeah, because perhaps there's no guarantee if you wanted to change you'd be allowed to change, would that be right?
speaker-1 (04:00.146)
no, there are no guarantees, but you can change and we have changed, but it is quite a bit of work again now to go and readjust that felon license depending on which way you want to go with the species, especially. So there is a bit of work. So it's I ideally you're getting it right from the start off, but it is still and some people may ask, why are we applying for a clear felon that is potentially ten years ago away from happening? And and I suppose for us it's to be prepared and it's to
Be prepared for bad days like January 2025 and Star Moon, where people hadn't Clearfills on their licenses. They had tenant license, but no Clearfell. And then all of a sudden you your plan changes completely and you're looking at a Clearfill that you hadn't planned to do. So it it's just to try to be as prepared as possible and and and as well to get the best value for money for when you apply for a felon license that you cover everything you can in for ten years.
speaker-0 (04:57.922)
Perfect. Okay. Well that makes sense. So let's say then that you've done your quick desk base survey and you're you're going out on site. Pick me through a couple of critical things that you might look for on site, the sensitivities that you're gonna keep in the back of your mind when you actually put all this down on paper then.
speaker-1 (05:18.344)
So look, I suppose for us and the geographical area that we cover, w water would be front and center for us. That is probably our priority when we want to any site. It's the first thing that we're looking for. So that you know, you have the layers on on the computer based system, but you still need to go through them on the ground and follow up. And when I say water, that can be everything from a weller relevant water course, which is a drain.
That is capable of carrying water to your actual aquatic zones and where they lead to. And are the standard watercourses or are they connected into very sensitive watercourses? So that has a huge part to play and importance. And that's all got to do with buffer zones, setbacks and sediment, and just that's extremely important, especially in the part of the country that we work in with fragile soils and high rainfalls, especially in the west.
know, it it's it's extremely important to be fully aware of those on site. Other things would include archaeology is a big thing. it's definitely then in recent times birds have become more important and for us to make plans for those as well. so it's it's just gathering a whole host of information off the site and putting it into a plan.
speaker-0 (06:39.744)
Yeah, Victor, just on archaeol archaeological features, then when I think of that, I think of ring forts and old castles. But the reality is is that it's a much broader interpretation of archaeological 'cause I think that even an old house ruin that's 120 years old, it has some archaeological value or at least it has to be recognized and protected in plans. Is that right?
speaker-1 (07:06.318)
Absolutely, yes. Exactly. It goes far beyond Ringfort's Dermot. It goes to townland boundaries is another example of a common one. And you're right, cottages on sites, which a lot of forester sites you know, it's quite common to find old cottages and pathways and roadways to them, and they can all be part of archaeology and you know, you have standard conditions to do apply when
Something just like a cottage, there is buffer zones around those and they are there to be protected. So yeah, it covers a lot of stuff such as
speaker-0 (07:40.108)
Yeah, and and I mean, I know this from sites I've been on where really you might only have the four walls of the cottage and you there mightn't even be a window frame still in existence, but that's just as protected as something that still has the roof, isn't that right?
speaker-1 (07:54.432)
It is, it is, absolutely. And they are on all the old maps. So it it is look, th they're not that hard to protect and they're easy enough to work around done with because they were never planted in on top of. It's sometimes it's the hidden ring forts that's on site that was previously due to previous land management, the ring forts may not be that visible on the ground and or lesser ring forts, and there is other different types of archaeological features.
that might not be visible to the naked eye. And that's where the the maps and the layers that DAFM have built up that we have access to are essential to make good plans and and to be able to recognize and see all these things, even if they're not visibly visible on the ground.
speaker-0 (08:40.002)
Yeah. So so let's move then to de desk base then, because you're dead right. You have a computer system that's organized by the government and it allows you to apply certain layers. So let's just talk about the you've explained the ring forts or the archaeological layer there. And let's talk now about the birds because you mentioned birds and in certain parts of Ireland there are protected species. So what what might pop up on our friend's forest site up in
North Leitram will say.
speaker-1 (09:11.736)
So I says the birds is I suppose probably to an extent affects Afar more, don't it? So when we're dealing with a felon license, harvesting the birds, you know, they're not it's not affecting them as much 'cause the forest is already there unless they're nesting in the forest. So for feeding grounds or anything like that, it's it's not as big as concern. I suppose the curdew is a good example there. It it is
very important bird to be protected now, but they wouldn't have any interaction with forest. It's more, but it can come out and as a condition on the license when you get your license that you may not be able to harvest that forest in in the bird nesting season. And that's more because of disturbance rather than actually the curlubin in the forest. But the you their nesting grounds may be adjacent to it. And for that reason it's to not disturb them while because their numbers are so low.
They're trying to do everything possible to increase their numbers. So it's that we wouldn't be working right beside them and potentially put them off a nest. So that's where an example of that is where you the license will come out with basic four or five months of the year that you can't harvest the timber off. Now there is exceptions that can be made. if it's essential, like the wind blow and stuff like that, where you can leave a buffer along the protected area or the bird nesting area.
you can leave a buffer of thirty metres of trees. Look at ideally we'd prefer not to go down that road and we'd prefer to just work within the months or outside the months that the is on the license, 'cause leaving a thirty metre corridor of trees probably isn't the best of idea and it means coming and going from the site. So ideally you'll just work on that forest when the when you're allowed to.
speaker-0 (10:59.992)
Yeah. Well, I suppose look at if you were lucky enough that you had an area of broadleaves that wasn't priority to get thin or clearfell, I suppose you could leave them on that side. But yes, I I get your point. you typically you want to get in and and do all your your work at the one time. so you also mentioned a layer that might cover water courses and that that water course might lead to some very critical water body.
What kind of issues does that cause then i for for harvesting operations or for the licensing process?
speaker-1 (11:35.904)
say issues it more just to raise the level of awareness and I suppose it's what's important is the qualifying interests. The potential one would be where the water course leads into an SSE. And depending on what that SAC is, what's its qualifying interests for it. So that can that can go back and increase setbacks and maybe more connected to refor and just the way we handle the water's edge and taking the trees away from that. I suppose it's to approach it
That all this information and layer building is that so you can actually approach the job in a planned way that you know exactly what you're going in to do and how you're going to do it and where extra caution needs to be taken. if if it's you know, if it's a highly center for like the freshwater pearl muscle or something there. Again, buffer zones and setbacks and timing is extra sensitive. So it is so it it's
Look at it is a fantastic system that we have access to and the amount of information and it's building year on year. Like the Wade and Birds would be a new one that would be put onto it now as well, that we can see where they are and where the hotspots are for them in the country. Heavily used by AFR forest foresters and ha fellandites looking for Felon harvest and foresters as well. It's a it's it's a massive piece of kit for us to have use of, so it is to be able to land things well.
speaker-0 (13:03.52)
Yeah. So so I mean, basically you're starting to put some of this information into the application itself so that the department can see that you've recognized the challenges that are gonna ha appear on site and that you already know before you get your license that you need to watch for A, B, and C. We mentioned archaeology there. I mean, what will you plan or what goes on the license to reflect the fact that there's a ring for it that
can't be seen that perhaps was partially planted over in previous times.
speaker-1 (13:39.064)
So I guess it's the biggest one that we have to try and recognise archaeology on, as it was from a forest owner's point of view, i is trying to position the road as far away from that archaeological feature as possible. Essentially that will lead to less possible disturbance and less cost to the owner's well, essentially. But if you can if you can keep any forest roads two hundred meters away from the feature, it just is a lot less work on everyone, to be honest.
So it's it's again, it's about planning and trying, is there an alternative spot to put in that? Because you have to dig to put into a forest road. So that brings in an extra layer s of surveillance from an archaeologist on site if it's within that buffer zone. So to try and plan to be away from those things and then, you know, when you get into the harvesting end of the things and the trees are too close or have been planted in the past too close to these buffer zones and archaeological features, that could take the form of
putting together a a plan of how those trees are going to be extracted from that zone. That that would usually take the form of of planning on selling trees away from the feature and maybe by chainsaw, you know, d dictating what type of machines can or cannot go into the zones. Again, increase in brash mats to protect the soil, that soil is not damaged in that zone. So just just to put again, it's to put it
proper plan in place. And sometimes that does, depending on the how sensitive the feature is, that will involve bringing an archaeologist in on site to work alongside us to to formulate that plan.
speaker-0 (15:16.216)
Sort of very good. Now, a as part of this application process, you draw up a map. And I've seen these maps and they'll have arrows pointing in different directions. What's going on there? What are you it's a two D map to me, but I can see what clearly seems to be a direction that you're gonna move timber in. But how do you kind of decide that between your desk survey and your on site investigation? What's important?
speaker-1 (15:45.874)
So again, that's where the the onsite sort of is very important. So you're going through the forest and you're deciding how you're going to get the timber from field A, B, and C back up to your loading bay. You know, we all know private farm forests we'd love a forest road going the whole way through the site, which makes it a lot easier, but a lot of times the forest road is in one corner and all the timber has to come back to that one corner. So you're trying to make a plan how that timber is going to become come back to that.
area. Now sometimes that may involve crossing watercourses or relevant watercourses. And it's putting on the plan where you're going to cross it and how you're going to cross that aquatic zone. And again, it's putting the plan in place. So again, choosing the best route possible. Not always easy done when you have a young plantation to go in and see what you're looking at, but it's to pick the best route back. Avoid really steep hills if possible. Try and
pick a forward and route that is going to be the easiest essentially to to get the job done and cause the least disturbance to everything.
speaker-0 (16:49.4)
Yeah, because the I'm I'm right in saying, Victor, that you try and put all the traffic onto one route to avoid messing up the the ground conditions across the forest, isn't that it?
speaker-1 (17:01.96)
It is essentially Demeragin going back to in an ideal world we'd have a forest road going from one side of the site to the other, but that isn't reality. So you do have to pick routes where your your forwarders going to travel on more rather than less. So I suppose where that starts at the very beginning is you're from the forward harvester and forwarder driver. If we're on sensitive soils, shallow, erodible in the winter time, we would choose to increase the brash mat.
on that site from the very start. So the harvester driver knows, right, we are going to extract the timber on this line predominantly. This is going to be the extraction line. So that might take the course of where the harvester driver will actually leave more material in the brash. So that could be leaving the last two lengths of stake in that actual brash. And the benefit of that is that he can put that under the meat the machines and it's protecting
In the soil because the forwarder is going to be travelling over and back and over and back across this multiple times, but with that extra bash in place from the very beginning, the soil is protected from the beginning and you avoid a problem. in our experience, it's in forestry and harvesting. It's to prevent the problem before it even happens. It's when you have problems with rotten and soil. It's very hard to correct that in the depths of winter when you have a problem.
So it is. So yeah, it's prevention is better than cure.
speaker-0 (18:32.6)
Yeah, no, absolutely. And and like what you're basically saying there is and I think it's important for owners to understand this, that there may be a very small sacrifice of some productive timber in effect to make sure that the the valuable timber and the vast majority of the timber can come out safely without causing problems. Isn't that right? But it it it wouldn't happen everywhere, I suppose.
speaker-1 (18:55.454)
No, it doesn't happen everywhere. And it's that I give an example there's a site we were on there in September back in West Mayo. Very sensitive site, very erodable soil, long, narrow site. So it all had to come down the one route. You know, and that was the the choice we made on that site was to put in from the very beginning increased material into that extraction route. And it it worked brilliantly. Like and the benefit, yes.
that there is a loss there, no doubt about it. It's a small loss to the owner. But the benefit is his site and his soil has not been disrupted. It's still fully intact underneath that. There was no silt moving on the site. So even through the bad weather we could keep working away. so i you know, there's the benefit for the owner is the job went off smoothly with no problems along the way. So again it's just about recognising the circumstances you're you're in.
planning for that. Now look, that comes with experience. There and you have to sometimes you have to make a mistake, maybe to find out how what the right way to do it is, and that goes for the harvester drivers and forwarder drivers and ourselves. So it is there is real benefits of working with people that have experience under leather belts and conditions that want to do the job right.
speaker-0 (20:12.758)
Yeah, because I I guess, Victor, if we're honest here, twenty years ago the felon license was applied for perhaps with less thought through for some of these these aspects, and perhaps it ended up being up to the harvesting driver and the forwarding driver to to to decide their own paths through the forest, or was that always standard practice?
speaker-1 (20:32.396)
Yeah, it i it was Dermot and and and look it it still is you have the harvester drivers essentially you can't be with them there all the time and they do have to make, you know, decisions on their own, and that's where having good harvester drivers and forward drivers in place is is worth every penny, you know. Look at we last winter, it's a great example. It it was extremely wet the whole way through the winter. Now in everything I'm talking about it i in this discussion, Dermot, I'm I'm relating.
To the west and northwest, and fully aware that conditions on the east coast of Ireland is a world away. And we've seen that this summer where they've had drought conditions, where in the northwest of Ireland we've had absolutely fantastic growing season the whole way through, you know. So I am always relating back to to conditions on this side of the country rather than the east coast, and there is a huge difference.
speaker-0 (21:23.99)
No, and then I guess again we we're just talking about our map again. The drivers, the operational team have this map as well. So let's come now they're gonna cross a waterway at a point that you've designated, Victor. How do they physically get the machine across that waterway?
speaker-1 (21:43.106)
So the the most common and practical solution to that, limit you have a load of material on site. So you build a bridge. And that is just done. We cut the logs into standard lengths as always, let that be a four point nine, three point seven, three point one. And in in a combination between it the harvester driver or the forwarder can driver can do it and they build a bridge using those materials and then they use the branches usually to top it off and tie it all in together and it works beautifully. It's
You know, it's an organic material that's growing on the site, it's right there at your disposable. And when you're finished, you just take it up and move away. And you it works it works brilliantly. So it does. There is limitations obviously to the spans that you can work with there on that. But in the in the most situations that it it works really well. So it does.
speaker-0 (22:33.174)
Yeah, so that just stops the muck and silt getting pulled down into the river as the heavy machinery are going over and back.
speaker-1 (22:39.914)
Exactly. And it's they're not they're not damaging the banks and causing stuff to fall in. So it's not.
speaker-0 (22:46.102)
I notice on those maps as well there's there's like safety points mentioned, there's entry and exit points, but there's also a storage point for fuel. Wha why do you do that, Victor?
speaker-1 (22:56.686)
So it's to stay away from again water is the key there, don't to to make sure that that storage and refueling point is is away from any relevant water course in the event that you did have a spillage by accident. That is not. It has to go potentially fifty meters before it can find a water course where it can get in to cause any problem. So that's why those areas are designated on the maps. It's specifically chosen
that it's as far away as possible from both from any watercourse or relevant watercourse.
speaker-0 (23:28.886)
Okay. That's brilliant. Yeah, yeah. Makes sense now when you say it. But again, to the layman, it these things they don't immediately pop up as obvious, but all all very obvious when you when you explain it through. There's another thing I wanted to ask you about. D does the layer that you're dealing with throw up any invasive species on the map, or is that the actual physical survey through the forest that would reveal them? And if they are on the site.
How do you plan for them in your felling licence?
speaker-1 (23:59.682)
Yeah, so again it it's an it's another thing that we have to take, you know, recognition of going forward or rather and no, there is no layers there. So this is very, very much on site problem and it's to record when you go out. as far as a felon license application now, if you recognise that there is one of these invasive species, we just say rhododendron or laurel or something like that, then you have to
put together an invasive species management plan. So your license, your felon license application is incorporating an invasive species management plan as well to go into the department and then that will be forwarded on to the relevant bodies. And and look at I I suppose as forest owners, you know, we can look at Laurel or Rhododendron and just they're not a big problem. And I suppose, you know, just literally yesterday there. I was out on a on a site in Mayo and
Juju the Storm Owen back. We had done a bit of a tidy up on the site. Now it was only little pockets of windblood that we'd taken out. But it's a it's an amenity parkland. But there was one laurel shrub, we'll call it, that was in the corner. Now it has been there. It was there for landscape. It's been become part of the amenity. Now it's a it's it looks beautiful, but it's there thirty, forty, fifty years. And it was absolutely amazing. They're not like, you know, the owner or not the owner, but the
People that's looking after the the woodland on behalf of the community, you know, said it's not causing a problem. And we just continued to walk on through the forest and all of a sudden laurel was popping up everywhere because we had tidied up some windblow there, maybe six months ago, twelve months ago. Yeah, it must be twelve months ago. And because the extra light had gotten into the forest floor, all of a sudden these seeds had got the chance to jump out of the ground.
And all of a sudden we're there hasn't been a problem for the last X number of years because there wasn't enough light or room for these to get away. And now all of a sudden it is a problem. They are jumping out of the ground everywhere that there's light getting into them. So it's amazing where you can think that you don't have a potential problem. And within a matter of a few years it can be. So it's it comes back to every forest owner's responsibility to to deal with it and not and definitely again I'm going to use the same
speaker-1 (26:18.476)
phrase again, prevention is better than cure here. It's, you know, when you only have a few plants on site, stop it then rather than when you're looking at it across ten, twenty, thirty acres.
speaker-0 (26:28.366)
Yeah, absolutely. So perhaps then l to take that obvious example, that laurel was identified on our sample site that we're talking about here. Would you just recommend cutting it out, Victor, and trying to poison the roots or how do you actually do it?
speaker-1 (26:47.33)
Deal with it. For me that'd be the you know, it's still very young, so it's very easy manual job at this stage. So the plants that are there in sight are in the height of your knee, but it's to get in now. And yes, your herbicide is the most quickest, easiest, guaranteed way of there you can cut them back, but we all know they will regrow with figure. So they do need chemical treatment to hit them on the head and the sooner the better that you're not having to go around the whole site doing
you know, acres and acres where it's the only very contained area at the moment.
speaker-0 (27:19.126)
Okay, well we've we've got through the application process now and and let's not even talk about the species that they're gonna put in. Let's assume they're going straight back in what with whatever species is being taken out. But let's say now that the application process is finished in the office. You've pressed the send button, the the the applicant our lady has applied and signed if necessary, and she probably paid you a fee.
But let's say it gets sent off. What what happens next and what are all the different stages that happen between it actually the send button being hit and it coming back as a successful application?
speaker-1 (28:01.902)
Yes. So I suppose this is the part that the forest owner doesn't see. Essentially the they don't really see all the checklists that we have to go through as well by submitting the application. But that application then goes off to DAFA and they will send that out to the regional inspector. And at that stage they begin the process of checking everything that we've submitted, but doing their they have a whole raft of
Extra checks to do on it and screening it to go through a process of deciding who they will refer that application on to. Now that application may be referred on to little or no one, but it on the other hand, if it's deemed sensitive for different reasons, that could be referred on to the fisheries, archaeology, ecology, the council, national parks and wildlife. and I'm probably still missing a couple of
speaker-0 (29:00.024)
Well, how do how about we take one of those just even because we've sent it off now, but it's landed on the desk of the of a local engineer in the county council. What what is he looking for or what might the county council observe about this site?
speaker-1 (29:16.312)
So I suppose from the county councils you and I I'm talking about the the road section here. So normally you have two sections of the council, you have environmental, then you have the the road section that forestry applications would land on. But from a road section, I suppose the regional engineer, their concerns are going to be are what roads are we coming out on? Are they structurally sound or is there a problem with them or are they weak? And it's the you know, at that stage they have the chance to comment on that.
whether what there are put conditions on it, what they want and advise on. Now usually we'd you know, we'd be working fairly closely with a lot of the councils and you'd have a relationship with that council engineer. So if they're sensitive sites, you know, when you're dealing with roads, we would much prefer a meeting on site to try and discuss the plan instead of coming back with just blunt conditions which is on the license. So pfft
That works best in our experience though it is, but that's what they're looking for is their sensitive bridges. And that sometimes that may just end up in reduced weights, reduced loads, different method of transport to get it out of the area. So you have to take every site as it comes.
speaker-0 (30:26.808)
Okay. And then let's say this is a particularly interesting site from an archaeology point of view and our file gets sent to archaeology. What what might they ask for or is there anything they might tell you that needs to be done on a harvesting site?
speaker-1 (30:45.496)
Yeah, so look we take our typical ring forth and then they come with various levels of importance. And that it it wouldn't be unusual that and again this will your license, remember, is incorporating the replanting. So it wouldn't be unusual that you would have to put a plan together of how your we'd say if it was an older forest that was planted maybe back in the late eighties or early nineties and it was planted too close to the ring fort, well then they will possibly request a plan
From a qualified archaeologist that the owner will independently hire of how those trees are going to be harvested safely out of that area without the it been damaged. And then on top of that, what could be quite common is from a to increase the buffer zone around that going forward, that it's not replanted. And maybe even outside that, that when it's been replanted, that it's been monitored by a qualified archaeologist.
Suppose the unfortunate thing from the owner's point of view is that's something that they may never have seen coming and a cost that they may never have seen coming down the line. These increased setbacks and having to get plans drawn up by qualified archaeologists wasn't maybe something that they had thought about. And back in the day they were probably planted too close to so. So that's the way they're usually handled. And when I say monitoring.
That means the archaeologists standing on site while you're doing the work on the site and they're monitored and looking out for any archaeological artifacts or finds or anything got to do with what might have been there years ago.
speaker-0 (32:25.824)
Victor, I'm afraid of the the answer to this question, but I I'm gonna ask it anyway. Who's paying for the archaeologists to be on my side or on on Tuesday's side?
speaker-1 (32:34.254)
It's very clear, Donald, the owner is paying for this. So there the owner's paying for it. Anytime an archaeologist has to come to the site, they are paying for that. Now there is a lot of the time the dip when the department inspector refers it on the archaeology that they are department have their own team of archaeologists in house. So they will formulate a plan sometimes if it's if they deem it non sensitive. Well, maybe I'm not using the right terms here.
But if it's lesser importance, they will form the plan for it and then we just have to follow that. But if they deem it more important, well then that's when they will request an archaeologist be hired at the owner's expense and that they go out and do the site work on the ground.
speaker-0 (33:18.718)
Very good. And then is there ever a reason why a a site for harvest could require an ecology assessment or is that normally only for afforestation?
speaker-1 (33:31.658)
It's normally for afforestation. We've done a few dermitt in maybe five or six years ago where we had sensitive sites, but mainly nowadays the department have their own in-house ecological team and it will be referred on to them regularly and they will do the ecological assessment on it. So that would so that's something that comes back and that is part of your felon license and there'll be
you know, a a plan and a list of conditions there upon potentially if it's a very sensitive site of how things are to be approached and followed the f for the future. So it is
speaker-0 (34:06.52)
This podcast is kindly supported by the Irish Department of Agriculture, Food and the Marine. If you're thinking of planting a new forest or keen to access information on financial and technical supports to manage your existing forest, then go to gov.ie forward slash forestry for you. I'll include that link and other critical details about the guest and this topic in the show notes. Now back to the chat.
So we have a lot of state bodies who have a certain expertise and concern for these sites. But what about the the local neighbors and the public? When I put in my application, how are they made aware of that and where can they access the information if they're concerned?
speaker-1 (34:50.732)
So when you submit a felon license application, that will appear on what is called the felon license viewer. So that's publicly available and anyone can access that and you can see the full plans online. So essentially the felon license is there for viewing. So it is. So that's the the public's way of looking to see what the plan is going forward here for this.
speaker-0 (35:15.038)
Nice. And and is there anything on the I know when I do a plan and permission to extend my house I have to put a sign up at the gate. Do is there a similar process then for forestry?
speaker-1 (35:25.024)
Yes, but not for felon license applications. For f so if you want to apply for a felon license or sorry, a forest road, yes, you have to put up a site notice. If you want to put a AFR application in, yes, you do have to put a a site notice on the side of the road. But for a felon license, no. We don't have to put up any site notice on the site for a felon license. Okay. It will appear online.
speaker-0 (35:47.47)
Perfect. All right. And so then let's say that you have dealt with some of the concerns that you've met the county council's engineer, you've addressed that issue, and there's one or two things that archaeology have requested we keep a particular eye on when operations are happening. But let's assume that the the license comes back and it's approved.
There's an appeals process, Victor, that can happen even when it is approved. Just explain briefly how that operates and that if somebody is only really getting around to seeing and being aware of it, how do they then object if they want? Because that can happen.
speaker-1 (36:34.84)
Yeah, so and and usually this goes on behind the scenes again. Durmots were where the owner and I have to say the Forester don't know this is happening. So this is what the the department and the the regional inspector will deal with. So at any stage, yes, a member of the public has the opportunity to put in a submission in and that will end up back on the regional inspector's desk while he's making
Or he or she is making their own decisions on the application, which will take several months at the very least. So they can make a submission and their regional inspector will take though that submission into account and deal with with it the way they see fit. And then to fast forward, then that may, you know, depending on how that discussion does or go, the that regional inspector will take that into consideration and they'll make their decision. And with Fragment's sake, we'll we'll say that.
They approve the license and the license is issued. That person that made the submission will be made aware of that, that the license has been approved, but they will be given the opportunity if they are still not happy, they can make an appeal within 14 days of that license been issued. And then that means that that license is withdrawn from the owner again and it goes to the appeals board, which is an independent board outside of the Forestry Forest Service.
And that appeal is is heard in due course and a decision is made on it then by those by that board as to what happens with it going forward.
speaker-0 (38:11.19)
Okay, and and just on that then, all of this takes a certain amount of time and we would just before I ask you the next question, from the day you meet our customer or you get that initial phone call to a typical time when the approval comes out. Let's not get into the the appeal, but just that normal process, is that three months from meeting, six months, nine months? What would you say?
speaker-1 (38:37.964)
W I seen stats released there only last week, Dermotin. You're you're on average you're looking at between six and twelve months. Now you have the exceptions, obviously outside that where you can have a license within three months, but you could also there is exceptions on the other side where you could be three years w waiting you know for i extremely sensitive sites. Okay. It has happened in the past. But your n your norm is i is six to twelve months. So it is by time the owner gets their license back into the hand. Now that
doesn't mean that it can't be objected to at that stage. But thankfully normally they're not because there's so much work and effort has been put into them over the previous six to twelve months of getting it right. So thankfully objections are quite rare.
speaker-0 (39:21.738)
Okay, well again that's it's good to be aware of that that you want to be at least factoring in a year and if you if you're made aware on the day of the phone call that you've an extremely sensitive site, yeah you you may brace yourself because you could be in for for much longer and hopefully you'll come out better than that. But now let's take the scenario where our h felling and harvesting Clearfell license has been appealed.
What will that add on to the delay? And are appeals ever completely successful? Have you seen many of them and and why would that even happen?
speaker-1 (39:58.136)
So suppose the speed is an appeal happens really is dependent on how busy the appeals board are, don't it? So and that's way outside of our control or remit. We've nothing got to do with it. So putting a timeline on that I wouldn't even like to try. you know, it it can it can be a month or two, but it also can be on the other end of that as well. It can be it turn into several, several months, so can before the sedition. Now usually
The the answer that comes back from the PE board is one of three is the most normal. So there's the one is where they agree with the regional inspector and Daphne's decision to grant the license and the license is upheld. Number two would be where it's an in between, where they they're quite satisfied with the application and how it's been dealt with, but they might want further information on they might want something adjusted on the license or tweaked in their view.
to make it a perfect application and they will so they'll set it aside and ask for that information to be done and give a path how it can be corrected. And then it that will take a few weeks or another maybe month or two to get corrected and the owner will end up getting the the license approved again. Or third is where the appeals board will come to the conclusion that there was a mistake here made in the application or a technic and technicality that's not correct or or incorrect or
Whatever the case may be, and they will revoke the license where in their opinion the license is invalid and they will ask for it to be resubmitted in a in a proper manner and and get it right the next time. Or taking both sides of the story into consideration and advise on how it could be done better. So at that stage, you're back to starting again. CR.
speaker-0 (41:45.07)
And I I'm guessing that happens now and again, but probably not entirely irrelevant. And and I'm guessing the vast majority of licenses are issued without appeal in any case.
speaker-1 (41:56.822)
Y yes, thankfully they are. They're vast but in in the current where we are in twenty twenty six, thankfully there are I would say ninety eight percent of licenses go through without any appeals or anything like that. And it and then look there is we all know there's certain s sensitivities in certain parts of the country where forestry might be the flavor of a month and obviously the objections are probably higher in those areas. But again, look I don't think if you have a valid
reason for an objection why that can't be negotiated on the ground with the person. And I suppose we would we would go to great lengths, you know, usually we'll be aware of a problem on the ground bef while we're making the application and we will go and do our absolute best to do that negotiation on the ground with whoever is involved, if it's valid reasons to that, you know, you have it, that it's going to go through the system. No one wants it to end up an appeal. It's it's not beneficial for anyone.
So it isn't.
speaker-0 (42:56.558)
Perfect. Okay. Well look at the I have the license now in my hand or Susan has the license and she wants to engage herself to manage the the full process for her. But why why do some and this is the default position in Ireland that a lot of forest owners will hand the entire process over to a company like yourself to manage to manage it for them. But why is that, Victor? Why is that advantageous than
Susan or Sean taking the whole process on themselves for the first time.
speaker-1 (43:30.734)
I suppose everything we've discussed there, Durma, for those reasons, we are in a hugely regulated industry. And you know, all those things that we've been talking about for the last twenty minutes, it's a very, very regulated industry. And it you know, they are con there is consequences if you get it wrong. And I suppose for for a lot of people, and remember this was potentially their first forest they've ever owned and it is you know, it's
It's a whole new set of skill sets that you need to develop to be able to carry out the job and have the confidence as much as anything to do it. And I suppose, look at I I don't think we're any different than a person building a house for the first time. The you know, you go to an architect or you go to an engineer or you go to a site manager to oversee it, that it the job goes off smoothly without a hitch. And and look at even for ourselves, you know, we're we're at this now fifteen years, harvesting timber.
And you're building experience all the time. During there's you know, every year there's a site with different conditions that you haven't encountered before. And it's it's a learning curve for everyone involved, you know. We're always learning, and it's just to try and prevent problems and mistakes and making it as an enjoyable as experience as possible for a forest owner. It is and the system that is popular in Ireland. Clearful is a popular system in Ireland.
is a med that we're harvesting and it's something that might only happen once in your lifetime. So I suppose a lot of owners would see it money well spent to get it right and come out with a s a successful end and and it goes according to plan.
speaker-0 (45:12.662)
Yeah. You you've a lot to learn if you if you do it all yourself. so so effectively, Victor, you'll identify the harvesting subcontractor who's gonna carry out the physical work. You'll manage them and the haul ears. You'll make sure they have their insurance and that they harvest the site correctly according with the harvest plans. You'll check with the mills and you'll do your spot inspections, you'll gather the money and you'll pay everyone.
including the forest owner at the very end of this. Now I'm just summarising your role there.
speaker-1 (45:47.96)
What doing a great job at it?
speaker-0 (45:50.35)
But the sting in the tail is what do they need to do, the owner? Now they've they're they've they've trusted you, you've come highly recommended. But is there one or two other things that they absolutely still need to do or should do while all of this is happening? I mean, have they an insurance liability?
speaker-1 (46:09.526)
Look at i in today's world the reality is they're not we're in a very litigious country. I I would still advise owners that they would have their own public liability. Look at every contractor that we have that comes onto the site is fully insured themselves. Okay. Western virus II co op is fully insured for any eventuality that happens to the site. But I'm not gonna pretend that that owner is fully protected in the country that we live at the moment. Heaven forbid if there was an accident, that
does not take away the the full responsibility from the owner as well. If that person that's involved in the accident wants to turn around and sue all three, the the contract, the subcontractor, West of Far as they co-op, and the owner, they're entitled to do so if they have a valid case. So it's yes, I would still advise owners to have public liability. Most people with farms have public liability. Most, you know, what's the difference in having a forest
I would advise owners to have public liability. Just for look at thankfully, we are accident free in in the length of time that we have been harassing and extracting timber. We go to great lengths to try and maintain that. And look, going back to again, it's the the level of importance that I leave on the contractors that are coming onto your site and the experience they bring is hugely important to achieving that and and staying accident free.
We have to take on new contractors from time to time and look at I'm not gonna sit here and say that every single job goes according to plan, fully the way you would have liked. but we are always always trying to bring the best in the field in to do the job. So the most successful outcome is there for the owner. Okay.
speaker-0 (47:52.878)
Okay. And everything we've talked about now, can I make the assumption that if the forest happens to be certified that you can provide all the necessary paperwork to ensure that certification now extends to the timber that's harvested, Victor.
speaker-1 (48:10.082)
Say that so you're sorry, just say that again, Dorothy.
speaker-0 (48:12.61)
what I'm saying is is that let's take the case where this forest owner is certified by some of the forestry certification boards. Is everything you do and the paperwork available to ensure that that certification can extend to the harvest process itself?
speaker-1 (48:28.664)
Well, certification starts it's it's well before that, Dharma So it is. I and look, to be honest, where we're at at the moment, there is not that many private owners in Ireland certified today. They do not have PESC or FSC certification. So it's it's still quite rare for private pharma and forestry to be in that situation. I suppose we've been monitoring it closely and staying with it and the ex minister had
put the first pieces in place to have a certification scheme that was accessible and affordable by all and that's starting to roll out now across the country, slowly but surely. but at the moment the reality is there there is not that many private forest owners in Ireland. When I say private, I'm talking about farm forest owners with individual forests. There is private owners, large private owners that have their forests certified, but there's reasons for that and why it's so much easier for larger
owners to become certified.
speaker-0 (49:29.454)
Perfect. Okay. And just a a a fairly random question here, but I know that when the harvesting team now are on site and the machinery's working through the the site they've identified their main harvesting rack and they're starting to cut timber. Just remind us how they select the highest value timber from each tree to make sure that the the amount of saw log is maximized.
speaker-1 (49:59.416)
So look, state of the art machinery. What those machines can do is is absolutely amazing and the technology that's on board is absolutely amazing. But and and I I've I'm going to repeat myself what I say at field is and and so forth and so forth. But the person on that machine is still absolutely key. They can have such a a difference on the final outcome of your crop. You know, we've
all the different sawmills around the country, but there is difference in the spec of each one of those sawmills what saw what they deem as acceptable saw log into their mill. So the harvester driver has to know which mills we are selling to and cut to spec that there is no issues when that arrives at the gate of that particular mill, when you've agreed your prices and all that is done beforehand, that you cut it to the spec required for that mill. And that's
I can't understate how important that driver is to get the best out of that forest, Joe, when when he knows where that product is going. And now that not just for saw log, that's all the way down for your pallet material, for your state material, and then onto your pulp. that he knows those mills outside, inside out and back to front, that you don't have problems or things arising down the line that prevents that timber from going to the destination at the great prices. So machines are fantastic.
But the driver is more important in my eyes. The machine selects the lengths. So it'll measure the diameter at all times, measure the length, so that's done for the driver. The only thing that the machine doesn't and isn't capable of doing is judging the deflection or a bend in that log, what's acceptable and not acceptable. Is it too branchy? You know, is is can you get away with sending in? Maybe there's a couple of branches, a couple of knots extra in that tree.
That's that's the driver's judgment to make that call, whether that turns into pulp or whether it's saw up.
speaker-0 (51:56.364)
Very good. Here's a thing now, when he's looking up in that forest, and and maybe this should have been already flagged in our application. But do you ever come across birds nesting or is I know Irish forestry can operate all year round unless there's a specific sensitivity. But is there anything to say about that, Victor? Because that when that guy gets in there, he's taking full trees out in in in a few seconds.
speaker-1 (52:23.628)
Yeah, so i it's an interesting topic. You just brought that up, Dunan, because it is something that came to European court level there this summer gone past. and it was questioned, so it was, because there is an obvious bird nesting season there, but forestry is exempt that we can still continue to harvest right through the summer. So d the debate goes on of how many nests is in forests or not in forests, or is it a good home? Is Sitka spruce, Norris Bruce, are they a good home for nesting birds?
And I ain't no ornithologist, dermat here now. And I forgive me f this is just our experience, what we've built up over the years. So if there's any bird professional out there that disagrees, by all means, they can let me know. But young spruce plantations is seems to be a good home for small nesting birds when the trees are young and they're lower to the ground. In our experience, when the trees come near maturity, where we're talking about their twenty two
twenty, maybe twenty-five meters tall, and the crowns of the trees are way up in the air. That seems it doesn't seem in in our experience that small birds prefer that for nesting. You go into the larger birds then the most common nesting birds we would see is probably birds of prey, is the most common one we would see nesting in spruce forests. I suppose what what can we do to to to manage that?
The one thing about the larger birds is they're way easier to find the nests. And you're we we've had European crews working for us over the years. And I suppose we can you can always learn a lot from someone else on the ways to spot them, find them, and look for the parent birds circling overhead. so I suppose that's what we try and do to if you're going into a clear field where you know the forest is thirty, thirty-five years, you're looking for bigger nests and you're looking for overhead circling birds.
And the nests are usually quite identifiable from the ground. And at that stage, then you can manage and plan to stay away from that area while the bird nesting season is in place, or whatever the case may be. there's there's obviously other birds we came across burn the colony once in a spruce plantation, and I suppose the easy option is there, just to put the job off until the back end of the year and leave it alone, you know. So a quick walkthrough sort of a from a harvesting point of view.
speaker-1 (54:46.488)
We're not going in in the air it is when the younger bird smaller birds are there. So I I would definitely think that it's more larger birds that's that's nesting in the spruce plantations as they get older and towards harvesting. Look at it, it's not a guaranteed approach. You can't always find every nest dermit, but I suppose the way I look at it is that forest has been there for the last thirty-five years, and that habitat has been hasn't been tampered with them for thirty-five years. So that bird species had
thirty five years of a free run and no interference whatsoever. And we will do our best that it doesn't happen when we're in there next June harvesting or whatever the case may be. And we will you do our due diligence and do our checks for those nests. But there's not many other land uses can say the same that a bird can nest for thirty, thirty five years with no interference or no disruption. there's not the reality is there's I don't know of any other land use can say that. Any other
land use activity nearly harvest their crap of some sort every year where there's possible interference. So to be honest, I I can live with that. So I can I I think we're pretty doing pretty well. So yeah, that's my view on it.
speaker-0 (56:00.246)
Yeah, no, no, no, no. It's good to understand that. We we've talked away here and we have mentioned that in the northwest and and across Ireland, it rain can be particularly severe at times. We wouldn't just call it monsoon, but now when you've had a couple of weeks of heavy, consistent rain, adding more rain to that can be a problem. Does that ever mean that a site harvesting operations may have to stop?
Or are there other wind conditions like wind and lightning that that could prevent harvesting from going ahead?
speaker-1 (56:35.662)
rain is the big one. Rain. That's the most common cause for us having to cease operations. And it's usually it's not the harvester here we're talking about. Harvester, you have to remember, passes across ground once across each piece of ground. So it's going down the line and it's harvesting the trees as it goes. So it's doing and it's the first time to pass across that ground. So it's not having any effect here. So the harvesting isn't the thing that needs to cease here in heavy rainfall conditions.
It's the forwarding. So the forwarder is the machine that picks the timber up off the site, loads it up onto onto its back. That forwarder could be bringing anything from five ton upwards on its back. So they're heavy machines and it's going across the same track over and over and again. So that's in heavy rainfall, that's the machine that more often than not needs to stop. It does happen. Look at every winter, every spring, there's days.
And certain types of sites, generally the ones that the alarm bells would be ringing. If you have an aquatic zone at the bottom of a hill in a forest, that is the one that we'd be going straight to and to stop on it. If you've yellow weather warnings, orange weather warnings for rain, you can nearly guarantee that site will have to stop. If it's flat sight, it's totally different, well drained flat sight, the chances are that site can continue on, no problem, that it's a lot easier managed. It's the sites on the hills.
Yeah, as a forest owner, you have to be aware if there's an aquatic zone at the bottom of it, well, then you have to raise your concern levels. You have to manage that in you know, because the potential for sediment to runoff and high rainfall is a lot higher. And the machines traveling across the ground continuously during the rainfall increases that risk. So that's why we stop machines on site. So it is. So yes, it does happen, Dermot, and it will continue to happen.
The weather is the weather. It's out of our control. We can only deal with it as it comes.
speaker-0 (58:30.946)
Yeah, yeah, perfect. And we're we're coming near the end. And I I still have one question or one or two questions I want to ask you because it strikes me that if we've had very wet conditions on a bad site, that you've used a lot of your brash along that main extraction rack. And so there's not as much brash lying elsewhere. And a lot of the brash has probably been compromised by that forwarder coming over and back.
But the reason I ask is brash removal of Irish farse sites is becoming much more common now that the brash is recovered for biomass. But it does does on a very wet site then could it be the case that that brass removal just simply isn't viable because of how much had to be prioritised for the extraction?
speaker-1 (59:01.55)
Yeah.
speaker-1 (59:20.984)
track? Yes, definitely. Again, it's totally it's hard to plan for, but winter twenty twenty five, twenty-six and spring twenty-six. now the market died for that brash material anyways, but that just was a coincidence. But even if it hadn't we wouldn't have been taking the brash off the sites because we needed the the weather, you know, last winter was horrendous as far as rainfall is concerned, especially in the northwest. And
We needed every bit of that brass to protect the ground and it it wasn't when we were finished with it, using it on the site, it wasn't in any fit state to be used for any other use. It was contaminated, it's dirty, you know, it's got soil in through it. So it's not fit for any other use. So at that stage, you just you leave that brash on the site. You don't take it off it. So you don't. So again, it's year to year.
Depends on the markets, what's available there, what the market is like for buying that brush and whether it's worthwhile recovering it. It's something that we definitely hope to get back to and continue with, but just the market for that material is is quite dead at the moment. So it is.
speaker-0 (01:00:31.0)
The second last question then, Victor, is how long after the harvesting completes and the timber lurries take the last sticks of timber off the site, how long after that can the owner expect to have to wait before they get a big fat juicy check in the post?
speaker-1 (01:00:51.246)
Well, I I suppose that's count every company, don't know what way they operate, but the main mills in the in this country are are excellent at paying and it's a fairly efficient system. So depends on the size of the site as well. But just personally speaking for ourselves, I suppose if it's a small site, just from an admin point of view, we'd like to keep it in one payment just from an administration point of view. But if you have a larger site, I suppose we would find monthly instalments work best for owners, so you're getting an income.
Of money from the start of the harvesting and it just builds confidence. Look at every individual is different and they've different wants or circumstances. So I suppose look at ourselves would work with whatever the owner wants from that regard. But yeah, and when it comes in and there's tax implications and all that, the owners have to decide for themselves and they'll come back sometimes and give you, you know, what way they want to be paid, how and when. Yeah, so we're flexible in that. But
I suppose if looked to us and we started a site there last week and the owner wanted an upfront payment, that's no problem. The the owner got an upfront payment and we go from there, we'll be doing monthly stage payments for that owner going forward then until the site is finished. You know, it's a b fairly big site, so it'll probably go on for three, four months. So it's probably going to be well into the new year before the final payment is transferred for that owner. So it is
speaker-0 (01:02:11.276)
Very good. Okay. Well that that gives people an idea. lastly then, Victor, any words of advice for anyone who's has a site that's seven or eight years off any potential clear fell and who's thinking about whether or not to bother applying for a licence now? What do you think? Should they should they go ahead and start the process? Or what would you say?
speaker-1 (01:02:34.156)
Look at Dammit, I guess, look at it was all as part of our mantra to be prepared. And thankfully that's we were unfortunately we were in the eye of the storm, but thankfully a lot of our customers had felon licenses in place if before the storm hit. It was just something we always recommended. So look at it's it's be prepared. I would absolutely advise anyone. If you have a plantation twenty years plus, you need to have a ten year felon license in place covering all eventualities that are ready.
Look at like currently we are the country is experiencing weak timber prices. There. There's no way of dressing it up or down. The timber prices are not strong at the moment because the market is flooded with timber, especially in some of the product ranges, the pallet, where our two point five, three point one, three point seven products are under pressure. That's not going to last forever. Unfortunately, it it will be too late by time for some if you were affected by Storm One. Unfortunately
You've had to harvest and you've had to go ahead and poor timber prices. But absolutely timber prices will bounce back from this. They will come again. Owners, private owners will probably look at harvesting differently. You know, well, I suppose we would have always spent years. Everyone in the industry would have been, you know, let the trees grow on, let them mature. The the storm is going to live long in the memory of a lot of people. so you may see sites being harvested at a younger age, but it it's again, it's the
If you've only got one forest, it's to be watching the market and when it's in a good position to be able to pull the trigger and sell your asset when the market is high, not look at inquire about the timber prices today and say, they're very good. And then I'm gonna go and get my film license and you realise this could take six, eight, nine, ten months to get. And lo and behold, when you actually get your license in your hand, the the market has dropped.
We're on a world market. Do you know, like everything that is produced these days, it it it goes up and it goes down and it's to be ready when it's when it's up rather than down. Yes, that's possible. So definitely I'd advise, you know, the new ten year system is is a great advantage to forest donors. It used to be five years was the maximum that you used to be able to get. Ten years is a great thing to have. It covers a long time. So I yes, I'd definitely be encouraging anyone to go ahead.
speaker-1 (01:04:58.71)
And get their license and have it in place.
speaker-0 (01:05:01.036)
Victor, that's brilliant. No, thanks very much for joining me.
speaker-1 (01:05:03.982)
You're welcome. I hope it's of some all that chat is some use to forest owners and help them maybe make decisions for themselves going forward. Perfect.
speaker-0 (01:05:15.086)
Many thanks again to Victor for his time in explaining all this. While you're here, please like, rate and subscribe to the channel, as it really helps the show grow. Thanks again, take care, and enjoy the woods.
